Personality Comparison: Big Five Personality Traits, 16 Personality Types (MBTI), and Enneagram Types

What is personality?

Personality is the collection of unique attributes, traits, and behaviors that define an individual. It’s a complex mosaic of characteristics, including one’s temperament, thought patterns, feelings, and consistent behavior across various situations.

Varied factors shape our personality – genetic predisposition and environmental experiences are two of them. Psychologists have developed different models to categorize these features for better understanding — among the most prominent are the Big Five personality traits model, The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI), and the Enneagram Model.

These systems offer insight into your personality by examining how individuals perceive their environment, what motivates them, and how they make decisions when interacting with others or coping with different life situations.

What are the 3 Most Popular Personality Models?

The Big Five Personality Traits, the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI), and Enneagram Types represent three of the most popular personality models studied and utilized today. The MBTI is a generally recognized assessment tool designed by Isabel Briggs Myers and Katherine Cook Briggs, categorizing individuals into one of 16 distinct personality types based on Carl Jung’s theory of psychological types.

This model aids in providing unique insight into your personality characteristics, how you interact with the world around you, and how you make decisions.

On the other hand, we have the Big Five Personality Traits model which has received substantial recognition for its research-based approach. It focuses on five broad dimensions – openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism – these traits are seen as inherent individual differences that remain fairly stable throughout adulthood.

Then there are Enneagram Types; while not traditionally research-based like Big Five or MBTI but still widely used for personal development purposes. It offers nine different character traits illustrating possible motivations behind human behavior which can help people control their emotions better to achieve their goals.

Each of these models offers valuable perspectives toward understanding our personalities in depth.

Got a Question about Your Personality?

Ask our AI Agent any questions about Personality Traits, Types, & Models.

Personality Type Comparisons in Myers Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI)

personality

The Myers Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) is a comprehensive personality typing framework that examines people through four key dimensions: sensing-intuition, thinking-feeling, judging-perceiving, and extraversion-introversion.

The system qualifies individuals into 16 unique categories based on the course of their conscientiousness in these areas. This widely accepted psychological assessment was crafted by Katherine Briggs and Isabel Myers during the mid-20th century to earmark inherent individual differences and potential strengths.

Each category in MBTI signifies a different mix of mental tendencies or preferences. For instance, an INTJ type (Introverted, Intuitive, Thinking, Judging) refers to someone who usually prefers solitude over social gatherings (introverted), has future-focused insights instead of relying on tangible information (intuitive), makes decisions objectively (thinking), and appreciates structure and planning rather than spontaneity (judging).

By identifying innate traits across these parameters, MBTI can be used as a tool for self-understanding and personal growth. It continues to hold weight among psychologists due to its focus on recognizing multiple facets of human personality which are often not featured prominently in other models like Big Five.

Warning:

Knowing Too Much About Personality Traits Can Skew Your Results. Take the MBTI Personality Test Now.

16 Personalities Comparisons Chart

The 16 Personalities Comparisons Chart offers a structured overview as per the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI).

Following is the HTML table providing a summarized view of these types.

Personality TypeStrengthsWeaknessesCompatibility
INTJIndependent, logical, strategicStubborn, judgmental, aloofENFP, ENTP, INFJ, INTP
INTPIntellectual, curious, flexibleInsensitive, indecisive, absent-mindedENTJ, ENTP, INFJ, INFP
ENTJConfident, decisive, organizedArrogant, impatient, controllingINTP, ENTJ, ENFJ, INFJ
ENTPResourceful, adaptable, quick-wittedArgumentative, insensitive, unreliableINTJ, ENTP, ENFP, INTP
INFJCompassionate, insightful, determinedOverly idealistic, sensitive, perfectionisticENFP, ENFJ, INTJ, INFJ
INFPEmpathetic, creative, open-mindedOverly idealistic, indecisive, too sensitiveENFJ, ENFP, INFJ, INFP
ENFJCharismatic, empathetic, supportiveOverly selfless, sensitive to criticism, idealisticINFJ, ENFP, ENTJ, ENFJ
ENFPEnthusiastic, creative, sociableOverly emotional, indecisive, easily overwhelmedINFJ, ENFJ, INFP, ENFP
ISTJReliable, responsible, practicalStubborn, judgmental, inflexibleESTP, ISTJ, ISFJ, ESTJ
ISFJSupportive, dependable, responsibleOverly cautious, sensitive to criticism, indecisiveESFJ, ISTJ, ISFP, ESTJ
ESTJEfficient, organized, practicalControlling, stubborn, impatientISTP, ESTJ, ENTJ, ESFJ
ESFJWarm, empathetic, responsibleOverly concerned with others’ opinions, emotional, indecisiveISFJ, ESFP, ENFJ, ESTJ
ISTPAdventurous, logical, independentInsensitive, impulsive, easily boredESTP, ISTP, ISFP, INTP
ISFPArtistic, sensitive, gentleOverly sensitive, indecisive, conflict-avoidantESFP, ISFP, INFP, ISTP
ESTPEnergetic, bold, practicalImpulsive, insensitive, easily boredISTP, ESTP, ESFP, ENTJ
ESFPOutgoing, friendly, spontaneousAttention-seeking, impulsive, easily overwhelmedISFP, ESFP, ESTP, ESTJ
16 Personalities Comparisons Chart

This chart provides an easy comparison among the 16 personality types, highlighting their strengths, weaknesses, and compatible types, thereby aiding in a deeper understanding of these complex personality types.

Personality Comparisons in the 9 Enneagram Types

The Enneagram is a powerful tool for understanding personality, as it dives deep into the internal motivations, fears, and driving forces behind the behavior. It categorizes individuals into 9 distinct types based on core beliefs about how the world works.

Each type has its own unique perspective and approach to life.

For example, Type 1 (the Perfectionist) is motivated by a desire to be good and right in everything they do. They have high standards for themselves and others, seeking perfection in all aspects of life.

On the other hand, Type 4 (the Individualist) values authenticity and uniqueness. They are highly attuned to their emotions and long for deep connections with others.

Type 6 (the Loyalist) is driven by fear and seeks security above all else. They are loyal and vigilant in protecting themselves from potential threats or dangers. In contrast, Type 8 (the Challenger) desires control and power.

They are assertive leaders who value independence but also seek justice.

These examples show just a glimpse of the rich complexity within each Enneagram type. By understanding these differences, we can better appreciate our own strengths and weaknesses as well as those of others around us.

Warning:

Knowing Too Much About Personality Traits Can Skew Your Results. Take the Enneagram Personality Test Now.

Enneagram Comparisons Chart

Below is an illustrative comparison of the nine different Enneagram types. This chart can help elucidate the unique nature of each type and the corresponding behaviors, motivations, and fears.

Personality TypeBasic DesireBasic FearKey Motivation
The Perfectionist (Type 1)To be good and rightBeing corrupt, evil, or defectiveDesire to be virtuous and follow the rules
The Helper (Type 2)To be loved and neededBeing unwanted or unlovedDesire to be appreciated and helpful
The Achiever (Type 3)To be successful and admiredBeing worthless or without valueDesire to be recognized and accomplished
The Individualist (Type 4)To be unique and authenticBeing inadequate or without identityDesire to understand themselves and their purpose
The Investigator (Type 5)To be capable and competentBeing useless or helplessDesire to understand the world and gain knowledge
The Loyalist (Type 6)To have security and supportBeing without support or guidanceDesire for safety and to avoid anxiety
The Enthusiast (Type 7)To be satisfied and fulfilledBeing deprived or trapped in painDesire for joy and new experiences
The Challenger (Type 8)To protect themselves and control their environmentBeing controlled or harmed by othersDesire for power and independence
The Peacemaker (Type 9)To have inner stability and peace of mindBeing in conflict or tensionDesire for harmony and inner peace
Enneagram Comparisons Chart

This comparison chart provides a brief overview of each Enneagram type’s basic fear, basic desire, and key motivation. The Enneagram system offers deeper insights into an individual’s core motivations and fears and can be highly beneficial in personal development and team-building contexts.

personality comparison

How do you compare the 9 Enneagram Types and the 16 Myers-Briggs Personality Types?

The 9 Enneagram types and the 16 Myers-Briggs Personality types offer distinct frameworks for understanding human personality. While both systems aim to provide insights into individuals’ behaviors, motivations, and preferences, they approach this task from different angles.

The Enneagram system categorizes personalities into nine primary types based on core fears, desires, and motivations. Each type is associated with specific traits and behavioral patterns that can help individuals gain self-awareness and personal growth.

On the other hand, the Myers-Briggs Personality Types are based on four dichotomies: extraversion vs introversion, sensing vs intuition, thinking vs feeling and judging vs perceiving. These dichotomies reveal preferences in how individuals interact with the world, process information, make decisions, and organize their lives.

The Myers-Briggs system emphasizes cognitive processing styles and attitudes towards decision-making processes whereas the Enneagram system dives deeper into the core motivations of individuals.

enneagram types

9 Enneagram Types and 16 MBTI Types Comparisons Chart

The 9 Enneagram Types and 16 MBTI Types comparison chart presents an insightful connection between the two personality systems.

Enneagram TypesMBTI Types
The Perfectionist/Reformer (Type 1)ISTJ, ESTJ
The Helper (Type 2)ESFJ, ENFJ
The Achiever (Type 3)ESTJ, ENTJ
The Individualist/Artist (Type 4)ISFP, INFP
The Investigator/Thinker (Type 5)INTP, INTP
The Loyalist (Type 6)ISFJ, ISTJ
The Enthusiast (Type 7)ENTP, ENFP
The Challenger/Leader (Type 8)ESTP, ENTJ
The Peacemaker (Type 9)ISFP, INFP
9 Enneagram Types and 16 MBTI Types Comparisons Chart

This table is a simple representation of each Enneagram Type’s most similar MBTI types.

The Myers-Briggs (MBTI) and Enneagram systems may have their own individual frameworks, but these correlations offer a comprehensive perspective on understanding one’s personality type.

Hence, this chart can act as a unique tool for further self-discovery and self-improvement.

traits comparison

Comparing the Big 5 Traits

The Big Five Traits, also known as the Five Factor Model, provide a framework for understanding individual personality characteristics. These traits include openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism.

Each trait represents a different aspect of an individual’s personality and can help determine how they interact with others and perceive the world around them.

Openness refers to a person’s willingness to embrace new experiences and ideas. Those high in openness are imaginative and curious, while those low in openness tend to be more practical and traditional.

Conscientiousness measures how organized, responsible, and goal-oriented someone is. Highly conscientious individuals are often diligent planners who prioritize their commitments.

Extraversion defines someone’s level of sociability and outgoing nature. Extroverts thrive on social interactions and draw energy from being around others, while introverts prefer solitude or smaller groups of people.

Agreeableness assesses an individual’s tendency towards kindness, compassion, cooperativeness, and empathy.

Finally, neuroticism reflects emotional stability versus instability. High neuroticism indicates a propensity for anxiety or mood swings whereas low neuroticism implies emotional resilience.

It is important to note that these traits exist on spectrums rather than as absolutes – most people fall somewhere between the two extremes for each trait. While one person may score high in extraversion but low in agreeableness (an assertive type), another might have average scores across all five traits (a balanced type).

Understanding these dimensions can provide valuable insights into our own personalities as well as how we interact with others in various contexts.

Warning:

Knowing Too Much About Personality Traits Can Skew Your Results. Take the Big 5 Personality Test Now.

Big 5 Traits Comparison Chart

The Big Five Traits Comparison Chart provides an insightful overview of the five key personality dimensions: extraversion, agreeableness, openness, conscientiousness, and neuroticism.

Personality TraitsStrengthsWeaknessesCompatibility
ExtraversionOutgoing, sociable, energeticCan be talkative, impulsive, attention-seekingCompatible with extraverts, ambiverts
AgreeablenessCompassionate, cooperative, empatheticMay avoid conflict, difficulty asserting boundariesCompatible with most individuals
ConscientiousnessOrganized, responsible, diligentMaybe perfectionistic, inflexible, overly cautiousCompatible with conscientious individuals and might have a conflict with high openness
Emotional StabilityCalm, resilient, emotionally balancedCan experience anxiety, mood swings, emotional reactivityCompatible with most individuals
OpennessCurious, imaginative, open to new experiencesMay be unconventional, overly abstract, indecisiveCompatible with open-minded individuals and might clash with highly conscientious people
Big 5 Traits Comparison Chart

This chart allows individuals to compare their own scores on these traits and gain a better understanding of their unique personality profile.

What personality types are similar?

The Big Five, MBTI, and Enneagram systems all provide different frameworks for understanding personality types. However, there are some similarities between them that can help us compare and find commonalities.

You can use this chart as a starting point to understand where and how the models overlap.

Enneagram TypesMBTI TypesBig 5 Trait
The Perfectionist/Reformer (Type 1)ISTJ, ESTJConscientiousness
The Helper (Type 2)ESFJ, ISFJAgreeableness
The Achiever (Type 3)ENTJ, ESTPExtraversion
The Individualist/Artist (Type 4)INFP, INFJNeuroticism & Openness
The Investigator/Thinker (Type 5)INTP, INTJOpenness
The Loyalist (Type 6)ISTP, ISFPConscientiousness
The Enthusiast (Type 7)ENTP, ENFPExtraversion
The Challenger (Type 8)ESTP, ENTJExtraversion
The Peacemaker (Type 9)ISFP, INFPAgreeableness &
Emotional Stability

By exploring these connections, we can gain a deeper understanding of how different personalities cover and diverge from each other.

What personality types are very different?

In both the Big 5 Traits and MBTI, there is a dichotomy within both of these personality models. Furthermore, there is an overlap between the Big 5 Traits and MBTI Dichotomies.

Big 5 TraitsMBTI Types
ExtraversionExtraversion (E)
IntroversionIntroversion (I)
AgreeablenessFeeling (F)
DisagreeablenessThinking (T)
ConscientiousnessJudging (J)
SpontaneityPerceiving (P)
Emotional StabilityNA
NeuroticismNA
OpennessIntuition (N)
ClosednessSensing (S)
Big 5 Traits and MBTI

The two biggest difference between these two models is that Big 5 is on a continuum instead of categories and MBTI does not have a type that corresponds to Neuroticism.

With all this being said, whenever two types or traits are at opposite ends of the spectrum then the people who exhibit these traits/types will be very different from each other.

For example, two personality types that are often considered to be very different are the extroverted and introverted types.

Extraverts tend to thrive in social situations, enjoying being around people and seeking external stimulation.

They are outgoing, talkative, and energized by interactions with others. On the other hand, introverts prefer solitude and quiet environments where they can recharge their energy. They are more introspective, and reserved, and feel drained by excessive social interactions.

Another contrasting pair of personality types is the judging (J) type and perceiving (P) type. Individuals with a judging preference like structure, orderliness, and prefer making plans in advance.

They strive for closure and enjoy sticking to schedules. In contrast, those with a perceiving preference value flexibility, spontaneity, and adaptability. They prefer keeping their options open rather than making firm decisions.

These differences highlight how individuals have unique ways of interacting with the world around them based on their personality preferences. It’s important to recognize these differences as each type brings valuable perspectives and strengths to various situations.

What is the Personality Compatibility between the MBTI Personality Types?

When it comes to personality compatibility between MBTI types, the belief is that individuals with complementary traits can have harmonious relationships. For example, an extroverted person may thrive in a relationship with an introverted partner who offers balance and understanding.

Similarly, someone who values logic and rationality (thinking preference) may find compatibility with another individual who prioritizes empathy and emotions (feeling preference).

Understanding the potential for compatibility between different MBTI types can be valuable in navigating interpersonal relationships and improving communication. By recognizing each other’s strengths and weaknesses based on their respective personality preferences, people can build stronger connections and work together more effectively.

Got a Question about Compatibility?

Ask our AI Agent any questions about Personality Traits, Types and Compatibility.

What is the compatibility between the Enneagram Types?

Each Enneagram type has its own unique characteristics and tendencies, which can influence how well they get along with others.

For example, Type One, known as “The Perfectionist,” tends to value structure and order, which may clash with the more spontaneous and adaptable nature of Type Seven, known as “The Enthusiast.”

To get an overview of compatibility, visit our Personality Compatibility Page or talk with our AI Assistant.

What is the compatibility between the Big 5 Traits?

The compatibility between the Big Five Traits can vary depending on the specific traits and characteristics of individuals.

The important thing to consider is that no one is just one trait. So in fact, we are all a mix of traits and this mix of traits interacts with our partner’s mix giving rise to the nature of our relationship. The first step to understanding this dynamic is taking a personality test and becoming aware of our own mix of traits.

Now, it’s important to note that compatibility is not solely determined by one’s Big Five traits.

Other factors such as shared values, interests, communication styles, and personal experiences and development.

Therefore, while understanding your own Big Five Traits can provide insights into potential compatibilities or conflicts with others, it should not be seen as an absolute determinant of compatibility but rather as one piece of the puzzle when fostering meaningful social connections.

Free Personality Tests 🤩

Get a “freakishly accurate” description of who you are and why you do things the way you do.
No Email Required.

FAQs

1. What are the Big Five Personality Traits?

The Big Five Personality Traits, also known as the Five Factor Model, include openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism. These traits provide a framework for understanding and analyzing individual personality characteristics.

2. What is the MBTI (Myers-Briggs Type Indicator) system?

The MBTI system categorizes individuals into one of 16 personality types based on four dimensions: extraversion/introversion, sensing/intuition, thinking/feeling, and judging/perceiving. It provides insights into how people perceive the world and make decisions.

3. How do Enneagram Types classify personalities?

Enneagram Types categorize personalities into nine distinct types based on core motivations and fears. This system helps individuals understand their dominant fears and motivations to gain self-awareness and personal growth.

4. Can I use these personality frameworks interchangeably?

While there may be overlapping concepts between Big Five traits, MBTI types, and Enneagram types, these frameworks capture different aspects of human personality. It’s important to remember that each framework offers unique perspectives on characterizing individuals’ behaviors, preferences, and motivations.

Resources